Skip to content

All solutions

Administration and technology

PEO analysis: comparing, joining or leaving a PEO

A professional employer organization (PEO) becomes a co-employer of your staff and bundles payroll, HR and benefits under its own plans. HRIS shows employers what a PEO really costs compared with running their own benefits program, and manages the transition for companies that decide to leave one.

What a PEO costs

PEO pricing is hard to compare because fees sit in several places: an administrative fee per employee or as a percentage of payroll, benefit rates set by the PEO, and markups on workers' compensation and payroll taxes. We put all of it next to a standalone alternative for the same employees.

When a PEO fits and when it does not

A PEO can suit a very small company that wants one vendor for everything. As headcount grows, employers often find they can get the same or better benefits, more control and lower total cost with their own plan, an HR platform and a broker.

Leaving a PEO

Timing matters because benefits, payroll and tax accounts all change at once.

  • Build the replacement benefits program and compare it line by line
  • Choose payroll and HR technology
  • Set the exit date, ideally at a quarter or year end
  • Run enrollment so no employee has a gap in coverage
  • Set up state tax accounts and workers' compensation

Common questions

PEO services: questions and answers

Is a PEO cheaper than a broker?

Sometimes for very small groups. It depends on the PEO's administrative fees and how its benefit rates compare with what your group can get directly.

Can we leave a PEO mid-year?

Yes, though deductibles and tax wage bases can reset. We model the cost of each exit date.

Do you analyze a PEO proposal before we sign?

Yes. Send us the proposal and we show the full cost against a standalone program.

Related

More from HRIS

  • Benefits administrationHRIS builds and runs your online benefits enrollment in Ease or Employee Navigator at no cost, processes new hires and terminations, and audits carrier records.
  • The HRIS client platformHRIS manages every client on its own platform, which tracks renewals, service and compliance deadlines and produces benchmarking reports and contribution calculators.
  • Employee NavigatorHRIS pays for Employee Navigator and builds, configures and supports it for clients, along with the Mineral HR compliance platform: online enrollment, self-service, payroll integration and carrier connections.
  • Hands-on employee assistanceHRIS takes employee claim, billing and benefit questions directly, so they are resolved by people who know the plan and HR does not have to referee.
  • Payroll integrationHRIS connects benefits enrollment to ADP, Paylocity, Paycor, Rippling, Gusto and Paychex so deductions match elections without double entry.
  • HR technology (HRIS) supportHelp choosing, setting up and connecting HR information systems, enrollment platforms and payroll so they share one set of employee data.
A family walking hand in hand through a green field

Get started

Tell us when you renew. We will show you what we would do differently.

A 20-minute conversation with a benefits advisor. No census required to start, and switching takes one signed letter.